The following comment was posted on Facebook by my friend Laurie in response to Part 4..
Wow, Gary...you have a real knack for writing. And your observations and opinions are based on the book you just read concerning Global Warming, correct? The name escapes me...but, I have to ask after reading all 4 posts, how do we know factories will shut down due to stricter regulatory controls, due to the fact that they will have to spend money ... to make money...in a safe and environmentally friendly manner (scare tactics). To date (particularly, past 8 years) they have had "free reign" to pollute to environment to kingdom come, so would it be so bad to have the scale back on emissions, after our last Prez GWB said "let-er rip"?
Thanks for the complements. Actually most of these four postings come from my own personal experiences and observations. I've been dealing with Climate Change issues in the refining and chemical bidness on and off for about ten years.
Regarding the shut down of plants, I can speak mainly to refineries (1). Refiners are willing to spend money to make money up to a point. However, a refinery, like any other investment has to provide a decent return over the long haul. Investing to reduce GHGs through energy efficiency will provide a little economic benefit but not enough to justify the costs on its own. Here's an example: Would you pay $10,000 for a new, more efficient air conditioner for your house if the A/C only saved you $20 a month in electric bills? Probably not. Just like all of us, oil companies, factory owners, etc have a limited supply of money that they can spend. If an investment's future looks bad, there is a point where you have to cut your losses and get out. All of this is a long winded way of saying, hell yes, operators will shut down facilites if the costs of complying with Waxman-Markey are too high.
Let's go to the more provocative part of the question, "To date (particularly, past 8 years) they have had "free reign" to pollute to environment to kingdom come, so would it be so bad to have the scale back on emissions, after our last Prez GWB said "let-er rip"?" I've also done quite a bit of compliance and enforcement related work over the last several presidents and I can tell you, unequivocally, that there was no "let her rip" mentality in regulatory enforcement by EPA or in the industry. During the late Clinton administration, EPA started an enforcement effort focused on several big, "dirty" industries (2). These enforcement initiatives carried on, pretty much unabated through the Bush 43 administration. In fact, if anything, EPA's enforcement activities (in refining at least) have become more intense in the past eight years, not less so. Convesations with colleagues in other industries share similar experiences.
I think that there is a fair debate as to whether this enforcement trend was because of or in spite of the policies of the past administration. Many of Cheney's efforts early on had the appearance of trying to undermine environmental policy, especially enforcement. There were some high profile resignations from EPA in protest of administration interference in their efforts to to better regulatory enforcement. But I think that these were counterbalanced by the rules -- which correctly make political interference in enforcement cases difficult to the point of impossible - and by the dedication of EPA and Justice Dept staff (3).
The perception about hands-off enforcement is fed in large part by the big environmental groups. From personal experience I can tell you that they are not afraid to misrepresent or distort things to create stories or situations that further their agenda. (I would go further on this but I better stop right there.) Let's just say that I'd believe any corporate publications long before I'd put much credence into what these guys claim.
Well, I've rambled enough.
Gary
Notes
------
1. The situation for refineries should resemble most industries except for Utilities. (Most utility owned electrical stations are regulated and have some sort of guarenteed economic return.)
2. Coal fired utilities and petroleum refining were the big targets, although there were some other industries targeted as well.
3. I kinda choked when I wrote that. Some of those folks I really do admire and some of them I don't like one damned bit. I'll leave it to others to figure out whom is whom.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer: Even though I work in the energy business on some of these issues, these opinions are mine and mine alone. There is no confidential or proprietary information in this post.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment