Saturday, July 18, 2009

Climate Change -- Part 3

We left Part 2 with the statement that the moves we are making to control Climate Change are all probably good, so long as we stay within the bounds of reason. So, are we doing that?


The bill working its way through Congress is the American Clean Energy and Security Act -- ACES, or as it still better known by the folks that work these things, the Waxman-Markey bill. Waxman-Markey requires a small reduction of Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions in the first few years culminating in an over 80% reduction in GHG emissions by 2050.


Between now and, say, 2030, or so, the reductions are probably achieveable within our current slate of proven and developing technologies. Achievable doesn't mean easy, cheap or painless -- it just means possible. After that, we will see application of new approaches to existing technologies, followed by a gradual transition to the "Green Economy" everyone likes to talk about. It might look something like this..

Step 1 Energy Efficiency and Good Things
As I said in Part 2, getting the first set of reductions requires us to do things that good environmentally anyway. These are things such as high energy efficiency in homes and factories, more hybrid and eventually electric cars, green building, and the like that are good for the environment no matter what.

Step 2 Transition
The problem comes when we get to reductions beyond what is achievable in this manner. At that point we get to taking more radical measures to reduce CO2 emissions. One example of this is "carbon capture and sequestration" technologies or CCS. CCS, which is often discussed as an option for electrical generating plants, refineries and other larege stationary sources, consists of collecting, or "capturing", and concentrating the CO2 from the industrial combustion of coal, natural gas or other fuels, transporting this captured gas, usually via pipeline, to a place with suitable geology and then injecting the CO2 underground into a formation where it will remain for thousands or millions of years.

The big problems with CCS are threefold: 1) It can only be used where there are nearby suitable injection zones, 2) It is applicable to large, industrial scale sources only and 3) It is very expensive.

Step 3 The Economy Changes
But CCS is an unconventional technology applied to conventional souces of GHGs. Real progress happens when the economy transforms to one in which everyday living requires much less energy. This is where changes in transportation, housing, manufacturing result in big reductions in energy demand and where power production methods such as solar, nuclear, wind, etc have come of age to the point where they make up a significant part of the power grid.

So that's how I see things playing out from a technology perspective over the next 40 years or so. The bad news is that the hard problems aren't technical. They are political. That's the subject of our next entry.

No comments: