Saturday, December 19, 2009

Irony of the day...

There are two interesting groups on Facebook that I just ran across. One is called "Soldiers Are Not Heroes." This group, a sick bunch as I see them, advocate just what their messages says. Then there's the "Petition To Remove Group "Soldiers Are Not Heroes" INVITE ENTIRE FRIENDS," a group that wants the first group kicked off of FaceBook.

While I am sympathetic to this group's cause, I am caught up in the irony: One of the many rights we ask our soldiers to defend is the right of free speech. People have a right to express unpopular opinions. People even have the right to be wrong. It's unfettered free speech that has been and will continue to be the defining agent of progress in our Country.

So, while I clearly don't support the first group, I can't support the second one either.

Sunday, December 13, 2009

Climate Change: eh, Thanks China.

In today's Financial Times online...

"China signalled on Sunday that it had abandoned its demand for funding from the developed world to combat climate change, the first apparent concession by one of the major players at the Copenhagen climate talks. "

You know, that's really big of them... Not making us give them money that we would borrow from them so that they'll do a little bit to help save the planet. And who says the Chinese don't have a heart?

I know the Chinese and the Indians keep getting tire of hearing this, but we can't do the global climate change fix without them. If you compare coal production between the OECD countries (i.e., the "developed world -- US, Canada, Western Europe and others) and the non-OECD countries (China and India leading the pack) you will see that the growth of coal is in the developing world. (Coal in this case is a good proxy for many types of GHG emissions.)

Now the rub at Copenhagen this week is that the non-OECD countries want the wealthier countries to pay them to reduce emissions. The rationale being, we created this mess and they need money from us so that they can afford to keep it from being messier. The argument makes sense to me in some places - Egypt, for example, with its choking air pollution -- but it makes no sense for the big growing economies of China and India.

Let's see some commitment to make it look like we're addressing environmental issues and it's not just a shakedown for money.

The world must take action on climate change at Copenhagen even if the science is not correct, Tony Blair, the former Prime Minister has suggested.

So the sub-headline reads in an article in the Sunday, December 13th online edition of the London Daily Telegraph.

Tony, I don't think that's what you intended to say. You were trying to invoke the precautionary principle(2) -- a holy law of the environmental movement -- that says, in this context, so long as if there's a reasonable probability that man made emissions can and will cause climate change, then we should pursue efforts to get these emissions under check.

===========================================================

Notes:
(1) I'll do some name dropping here. One time, while in London, I was stood up in a meeting with a guy who had to go meet with Tony Blair instead (while Blair was PM). Instead I talked with the guy on a telecon while he took the train to Central London for his meeting at 10 Downing Street. Impressed?

(2) The precautionary principle is a moral and political principle which states that if an action or policy might cause severe or irreversible harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of a scientific consensus that harm would not ensue, the burden of proof falls on those who would advocate taking the action. (reference)