Saturday, December 19, 2009

Irony of the day...

There are two interesting groups on Facebook that I just ran across. One is called "Soldiers Are Not Heroes." This group, a sick bunch as I see them, advocate just what their messages says. Then there's the "Petition To Remove Group "Soldiers Are Not Heroes" INVITE ENTIRE FRIENDS," a group that wants the first group kicked off of FaceBook.

While I am sympathetic to this group's cause, I am caught up in the irony: One of the many rights we ask our soldiers to defend is the right of free speech. People have a right to express unpopular opinions. People even have the right to be wrong. It's unfettered free speech that has been and will continue to be the defining agent of progress in our Country.

So, while I clearly don't support the first group, I can't support the second one either.

Sunday, December 13, 2009

Climate Change: eh, Thanks China.

In today's Financial Times online...

"China signalled on Sunday that it had abandoned its demand for funding from the developed world to combat climate change, the first apparent concession by one of the major players at the Copenhagen climate talks. "

You know, that's really big of them... Not making us give them money that we would borrow from them so that they'll do a little bit to help save the planet. And who says the Chinese don't have a heart?

I know the Chinese and the Indians keep getting tire of hearing this, but we can't do the global climate change fix without them. If you compare coal production between the OECD countries (i.e., the "developed world -- US, Canada, Western Europe and others) and the non-OECD countries (China and India leading the pack) you will see that the growth of coal is in the developing world. (Coal in this case is a good proxy for many types of GHG emissions.)

Now the rub at Copenhagen this week is that the non-OECD countries want the wealthier countries to pay them to reduce emissions. The rationale being, we created this mess and they need money from us so that they can afford to keep it from being messier. The argument makes sense to me in some places - Egypt, for example, with its choking air pollution -- but it makes no sense for the big growing economies of China and India.

Let's see some commitment to make it look like we're addressing environmental issues and it's not just a shakedown for money.

The world must take action on climate change at Copenhagen even if the science is not correct, Tony Blair, the former Prime Minister has suggested.

So the sub-headline reads in an article in the Sunday, December 13th online edition of the London Daily Telegraph.

Tony, I don't think that's what you intended to say. You were trying to invoke the precautionary principle(2) -- a holy law of the environmental movement -- that says, in this context, so long as if there's a reasonable probability that man made emissions can and will cause climate change, then we should pursue efforts to get these emissions under check.

===========================================================

Notes:
(1) I'll do some name dropping here. One time, while in London, I was stood up in a meeting with a guy who had to go meet with Tony Blair instead (while Blair was PM). Instead I talked with the guy on a telecon while he took the train to Central London for his meeting at 10 Downing Street. Impressed?

(2) The precautionary principle is a moral and political principle which states that if an action or policy might cause severe or irreversible harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of a scientific consensus that harm would not ensue, the burden of proof falls on those who would advocate taking the action. (reference)

Friday, July 31, 2009

A Healthy Healthcare Conversation

Greg Gillette, an old pal from Tascosa HS, and I got into a debate on his Facebook page regarding healthcare reform. With Greg's permission, I've copied it here so that it has a bit different (not wider) distribution. Feel free to weigh in with your comments...

++++++++++++++++++++++

Greg Gillette In Canada they have a lottery in the various cities across the country.......for a family Doctor. That's right, people have to wait on a city lottery to get on a family physicians patient list. Uhhhuhhh. You heard it, we want to be like Canada, and France, and England....because????????


Gary Scoggin
The difference is that in the US, some people are hoping to win the lottery so that they can afford to see a doctor.

Greg Gillette
Gary, very good point and I agree. I.e. in Amarillo, they have worked out a method to take care of any person that needs healthcare. There is access and coverage for everyone. Amarillo has one of the highest indigent care ratios in the state, precisely because word of mouth gets out to migrant workers, and they come to the city in droves. The city funds this multi-million dollar allocation in a contract with the old Northwest Texas hospital. The hospital must care for these individuals without respect to any factor, including ability to pay. The model I am suggesting would focus funding at community, and city levels. It would be supported by area healthcare concerns of all types, private physicians. and government physicians and facilities. In addition you could allow private healthcare facilities to be directly allowed to participate. You could also allow for unlimited tax credits to individuals who could contribute to charitable healthcare funded facilities, and physicians.

The important factor is to allow federal tax credits to individuals and corporations to fund community based healthcare programs. Mathematically, this type of predominantly privately funded healthcare solution, would be more fiscally and actuarily efficient than a Federally based program.

Today, Medicare/Medicaid submissions for reimbursements are rejected at a 4 out of 7 ratio. That means that they have to be refiled/resubmitted before the government pays. That factor would always be present under a federally based program, because the Federal system will never be interconnected with private individuals.....unless privacy is no longer important to the average US Citizen.

The fact is that federal programs like Medi-Care and Medi-Caid , have become so big that reimbursements have become the biggest problem in our entire healthcare system. You have to charge federal programs more, in order to offset the cash flow problems they create. This means that often they are billed twice what a
privately funded, and administered program. There are physicians that are going broke with over 30000 patients here in Dallas waiting on Medicare/medicaid reimbursement. This is an unacceptable business risk for the private healthcare provider. The problems we face are not all because of federal programs. Physicians have to over-treat because of litigation concerns. This adds probably an additional 20% to our medical bills alone.

So what I am saying is that mathematically healthcare should always be a private enterprise/charity. Perhaps it is true there is excess. Make the program community based, and accountability will be immensely improved. Technology is our friend here, it can also provide a tremendous economy of scale shift to us. The nation in a panic could make a mistake that is permanently crippling to our economy. Insurance is not the answer, it is part of an additional cost incursion. Treat the people, the system should be there to support, create it at the community level .

Gary Scoggin
Greg.... i couldn't agree with you more. Just like schools, I think the best health care delivery systems are focused and run at the local level. In the best system, the role of the Fed Gov't should be to set standards of care and to help provide funding. I see health care for everyone as a moral imperative first, and an economic imperative second. I think of it as the story of the Good Samaritan, writ large.

(Greg, do you have any problems if I cut and copy your post over to my blog? The two or three people that read it would find it interesting.)


Greg Gillette
Not at all. And thanks for your comments, if we work together, we can solve this issue. It's as important as ever for our generation to resolve healthcare for the generations to come.

Sunday, July 19, 2009

Climate Change -- Questions from the Audience

The following comment was posted on Facebook by my friend Laurie in response to Part 4..

Wow, Gary...you have a real knack for writing. And your observations and opinions are based on the book you just read concerning Global Warming, correct? The name escapes me...but, I have to ask after reading all 4 posts, how do we know factories will shut down due to stricter regulatory controls, due to the fact that they will have to spend money ... to make money...in a safe and environmentally friendly manner (scare tactics). To date (particularly, past 8 years) they have had "free reign" to pollute to environment to kingdom come, so would it be so bad to have the scale back on emissions, after our last Prez GWB said "let-er rip"?

Thanks for the complements. Actually most of these four postings come from my own personal experiences and observations. I've been dealing with Climate Change issues in the refining and chemical bidness on and off for about ten years.

Regarding the shut down of plants, I can speak mainly to refineries (1). Refiners are willing to spend money to make money up to a point. However, a refinery, like any other investment has to provide a decent return over the long haul. Investing to reduce GHGs through energy efficiency will provide a little economic benefit but not enough to justify the costs on its own. Here's an example: Would you pay $10,000 for a new, more efficient air conditioner for your house if the A/C only saved you $20 a month in electric bills? Probably not. Just like all of us, oil companies, factory owners, etc have a limited supply of money that they can spend. If an investment's future looks bad, there is a point where you have to cut your losses and get out. All of this is a long winded way of saying, hell yes, operators will shut down facilites if the costs of complying with Waxman-Markey are too high.

Let's go to the more provocative part of the question, "To date (particularly, past 8 years) they have had "free reign" to pollute to environment to kingdom come, so would it be so bad to have the scale back on emissions, after our last Prez GWB said "let-er rip"?" I've also done quite a bit of compliance and enforcement related work over the last several presidents and I can tell you, unequivocally, that there was no "let her rip" mentality in regulatory enforcement by EPA or in the industry. During the late Clinton administration, EPA started an enforcement effort focused on several big, "dirty" industries (2). These enforcement initiatives carried on, pretty much unabated through the Bush 43 administration. In fact, if anything, EPA's enforcement activities (in refining at least) have become more intense in the past eight years, not less so. Convesations with colleagues in other industries share similar experiences.

I think that there is a fair debate as to whether this enforcement trend was because of or in spite of the policies of the past administration. Many of Cheney's efforts early on had the appearance of trying to undermine environmental policy, especially enforcement. There were some high profile resignations from EPA in protest of administration interference in their efforts to to better regulatory enforcement. But I think that these were counterbalanced by the rules -- which correctly make political interference in enforcement cases difficult to the point of impossible - and by the dedication of EPA and Justice Dept staff (3).

The perception about hands-off enforcement is fed in large part by the big environmental groups. From personal experience I can tell you that they are not afraid to misrepresent or distort things to create stories or situations that further their agenda. (I would go further on this but I better stop right there.) Let's just say that I'd believe any corporate publications long before I'd put much credence into what these guys claim.

Well, I've rambled enough.

Gary


Notes
------
1. The situation for refineries should resemble most industries except for Utilities. (Most utility owned electrical stations are regulated and have some sort of guarenteed economic return.)
2. Coal fired utilities and petroleum refining were the big targets, although there were some other industries targeted as well.
3. I kinda choked when I wrote that. Some of those folks I really do admire and some of them I don't like one damned bit. I'll leave it to others to figure out whom is whom.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer: Even though I work in the energy business on some of these issues, these opinions are mine and mine alone. There is no confidential or proprietary information in this post.

Climate Change -- Part 4

At the end of Part 3, I closed with the assertion that "The bad news is that the hard problems aren't technical. They are political." Let's talk more about that.

First, let's start with the overall scheme for reducing emissions of Greenhouse Gases. (also referred to as GHG's, these include carbon dioxide (CO2), methane and a whole bunch of other gases, including water vapor, but the gas of principal concern is CO2.) The focus of Waxman-Markey is on the industrial operator -- the power plant, the refinery, the steel mill, etc, not on the consumer. The consumer pays in the end. We'll get to that later but first it helps to understand the overall construct. There are three possible approaches for regulating these emissions: A command and control regime, a tax on emissions, and a market-based system. Let's look at each in turn.

Command and Control
This is the basic system used in most US environmental regulations today. An agency, often EPA or a state agency acting on EPA's behalf, issues a regulation or a permit telling industries exactly how much they can pollute and, often, exactly how to control things. This approach can work in addressing local problems -- a community or a defined geographic area -- but it doesn't apply well to the issue of Climate Change. (1) First, this is because GHGs are a global problem and progress in one geographic area doesn't equate to progress across the entire planet. (2) This approach would have the effect of creating economically and ususally technically impossible requirements on many power plants, refineries, steel mills and other manufacturing causing many to close down or radically change their mode of operation.

This approach is favored by many environmental groups such as Sierra Club, Natural Resources Defense Council and Greenpeace because it causes the most societal disruption and is the quickest way to create a radical reordering of the economy causing massive immediate investment in new, sustainable power sources and immediate changes in individual behaviors. (I know I'm being harsh on those folks, but look past their rhetoric at their actions.)

Tax on Emissions -- The Carbon Tax
This concept is to simply set a tax rate for CO2 emissions, say $50/ton, and let each individual operator figure out his own economics of reducing emissions. This provides economic certainty for the emitter. If he emits x tons per year and the tax is $y/ton then his annual cost is $xy. What this doesn't provide is certainty around the amount of emissions that will be reduced. Since each operator can elect to either reduce emissions or pay the tax, or some of both, then it becomes unpredictable across the economy as to what will happen.(3)

Market-based system -- Cap and Trade
A market-based emissions management system works by using the marketplace to allocate emissions in the most efficient manner. The most common version of this, and the centerpiece of the Waxman-Markey bill is the Cap and Trade system. This system, similar to a GHG regulation system that has been in place in Europe for several years, works as follows:

The amount of GHG emissions allowed in the economy is capped each year. Year on year, the amount of allowable emissions decreases. (See the graph in Part 3, it shows the planned reduction in allowable emissions.) This is the "Cap"
Each year, operators in industries that emit GHGs are granted "allowances" to cover all or part of their emissions.
If an operator's emissions exceed his allowances, then he must purchase allowances from somebody that has extra. If the operator's emissions are less than his allowances he's free to sell them to somebody that needs them.
This exchange of the allowances creates a market place. The laws of supply and demand set the prices. This is the "trade."

Overall, the system makes economic and environmental sense. Since the total amount of emissions in the economy is capped, then there is certainty in attaining the reduction goals. While a market-based system doesn't guarentee cost certainty for the operator, it does an efficient and transparent allocation method and does enable a smart operator to do good planning.

Now, so much for the theoretical. Let's get to the real world and real politics. That's where we're going in Part 5.


Notes
-----------
For more on all of this, here's a good reference. Now the footnotes:

(1) Command and control for conventional air pollution sources as applied in the US is very inefficient and ineffective compared to how it is often applied in Europe and many other countries. A topic for another day.
(2) This begs the question: What good does it do for the US, Europe and Canada to crank down on GHGs while India and China go nuts in increasing theirs? The short answer is that's why the Kyoto Treaty failed 99-0 in the Senate. But it's an interesting question that I'll try to get to in a future installment.
(3) This is the approach favored by some US energy companies , most notably Exxon-Mobil. BP and Shell, both European companies advocated for a cap and trade system. My own opinion is that each side favored the system that played into their strengths. Exxon is a financial powerhouse that can plow through the worst of times and works hard to minimize its financial risks. BP and Shell, on the other hand, are much more cash constrained and, importantly, have very sophisticated energy trading operations which gives them a set of competencies needed to effectively play the emissions trading game.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer: Even though I work in the energy business on some of these issues, these opinions are mine and mine alone. There is no confidential or proprietary information in this post.

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Climate Change -- Part 3

We left Part 2 with the statement that the moves we are making to control Climate Change are all probably good, so long as we stay within the bounds of reason. So, are we doing that?


The bill working its way through Congress is the American Clean Energy and Security Act -- ACES, or as it still better known by the folks that work these things, the Waxman-Markey bill. Waxman-Markey requires a small reduction of Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions in the first few years culminating in an over 80% reduction in GHG emissions by 2050.


Between now and, say, 2030, or so, the reductions are probably achieveable within our current slate of proven and developing technologies. Achievable doesn't mean easy, cheap or painless -- it just means possible. After that, we will see application of new approaches to existing technologies, followed by a gradual transition to the "Green Economy" everyone likes to talk about. It might look something like this..

Step 1 Energy Efficiency and Good Things
As I said in Part 2, getting the first set of reductions requires us to do things that good environmentally anyway. These are things such as high energy efficiency in homes and factories, more hybrid and eventually electric cars, green building, and the like that are good for the environment no matter what.

Step 2 Transition
The problem comes when we get to reductions beyond what is achievable in this manner. At that point we get to taking more radical measures to reduce CO2 emissions. One example of this is "carbon capture and sequestration" technologies or CCS. CCS, which is often discussed as an option for electrical generating plants, refineries and other larege stationary sources, consists of collecting, or "capturing", and concentrating the CO2 from the industrial combustion of coal, natural gas or other fuels, transporting this captured gas, usually via pipeline, to a place with suitable geology and then injecting the CO2 underground into a formation where it will remain for thousands or millions of years.

The big problems with CCS are threefold: 1) It can only be used where there are nearby suitable injection zones, 2) It is applicable to large, industrial scale sources only and 3) It is very expensive.

Step 3 The Economy Changes
But CCS is an unconventional technology applied to conventional souces of GHGs. Real progress happens when the economy transforms to one in which everyday living requires much less energy. This is where changes in transportation, housing, manufacturing result in big reductions in energy demand and where power production methods such as solar, nuclear, wind, etc have come of age to the point where they make up a significant part of the power grid.

So that's how I see things playing out from a technology perspective over the next 40 years or so. The bad news is that the hard problems aren't technical. They are political. That's the subject of our next entry.

Loyalty Oaths in Venzuela

From this story: "Union leaders on Wednesday condemned a warning by President Hugo Chavez's oil minister that workers in the oil industry should be socialists or face suspicions they are conspiring against the government."

This is the latest in Chavez' efforts to become the next Fidel Castro. First you control the military, then expropriate land from the wealthy. Next take over the biggest industry (PdVSA), control the press and demand loyalty oaths to keep your jobs.

Chavez is a thug.

Saturday, July 4, 2009

Al & Jesse vie for MJ's spotlight


Revs. Sharpton, and Jesse Jackson Jockey for Position in Michael Jackson's Memorial Spotlight. This is one of my favorite stories of the week.


I absolutely love watching these two guys wrestle each other for the spotlight. Each is trying to outdo each other to avoid being hung with the label, "America's most irrelevant man." So, when I first saw this picture of Sharpton with MJ's dad a few days ago, I thought that maybe Sharpton had the faded leader duty pager for the weekend and was called out first. But it turns out he just beat Jesse to the newsconference.

Friday, July 3, 2009

Climate Change -- Part 2

Is Climate Change for Real?

Anybody that says that they unequviocally, absolutely know the answer to this is either a fool or a liar. Or at least misinformed.

A few miscellaneous facts: (Or at least I believe them to be facts.)

We have a hundred or so years of reliable temperature measurement. I'm not a climatologist but I did take a lot of math in college and to take 100 points and then try to predict the next 100 points in a function that plays out over thousands of years is "an error prone metodology" to say the least. (Its one of those situations where the standard deviation is so large that is masks the trend.) The bottom line is this: We can't use temperature measurements or weather patterns to make a case one way or another.

We do have a lot of data on historical CO2 levels in the atmosphere. Ice core samples from cold places like Antartica, Greenland and Amarillo show that CO2 levels are increasing. And that increase correlates with the beginning of the industrial revolution when the use of fossil fuels increased dramatically.

Water vapor is by far the most prevalent greenhouse gas present in the atmosphere. But that doesn't diminish the role that other GHGs play in regulating the earth's temperature.

There are many scientists that believe that a CO2 level of 385 ppm may be the level where climate change really takes off. We're approaching that level right now. There is no doubt that trend is up.

The concern over the loss of polar ice habitats has caused the US to list the Polar Bear as an endangered species. However, despite what you may have seen in an Al Gore movie, the Polar Bear population is increasing, not decreasing. But wait a second. The population is increasing due to controls on hunting. So will the population decrease as polar ice melts? If it melts.

There are plenty of other facts on both sides of the debate. All researched, sworn and subscribed to by a bunch of really smart people with the best of intentions.

So, here's what I believe about whether or not Climate Change is a fact:
I don't know.

My intuition is that there is probably something there and that wise precautions are in order. In general, the things that we can do to address climate change are good things to do environmentally anyway. So there's no downside as long as we stay within the bounds of reason.

So are we staying within those bounds? That's the topic for our next posting.

Climate Change -- Part 1

A few days ago I'm watching Juan Williams (one of the house liberals at Fox News) interview White House Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton about the American Climate and Energy Security (ACES)bill passed by the House last week. Every time Burton got pressed into a corner -- which was often -- he referred to ACES as really a jobs bill.

To which I yelled at my TV, "Man up, boy! ACES is a lot of things, but IT AIN'T NO JOBS BILL! You and your boss and your boss's boss need to have the huevos to admit that!"

This is the kind of stuff that gets in the way of reasonable discussion about Climate Change and, especially, climate change legislation. For some reason, what should be a matter of science has been turned into a political litmus test. The conservatives line up behind those that think its all hippie hogwash and the liberals line up behind those that think that evil corporations are content to destroy life on earth just so they can make greedy profits in the meantime.

I'm getting tired of all the misinformation and name calling. That's why I thought I'd try to rejuvinate my little used corner of the Internet to shed some reason on all of this. So this is the first of what I hope are several posts that slap some of you to your senses.

Saturday, June 13, 2009

Democracy In Iran

Given the events of Sunday June 14, I may have spoken too soon.
===================================================================


I love elections. And I'm always fascinated when democracy happens in places that don't take it for granted. Take Iran for example. According to the official results, Iran's chief village idiot, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, is the clear winner with 62%. The other side doesn't seem to agree and they've taken to the streets claiming that Ahmadinejad had lied, cheated and stolen his way to victory.

But did he? Probably not. Although there was definitely some funny business going on -- CNN reported that "Technology has been a key tactic in politically mobilizing young people in Iran, but text messaging has not been working in Iran over recent days" -- the fact that with a turnout over 80%, it could be that, like it or not, Ahmadinejad represents what the majority of the Iranian people want. After all, they elected him once already.

In a column posted earlier today on the Newsweek Website, Christopher Dickey addresses this,

"It appears that the working classes and the rural poor—the people who do not much look or act or talk like us—voted overwhelmingly for the scruffy, scrappy president who looks and acts and talks more or less like them. And while Mousavi and his supporters are protesting and even scuffling with police, they are just as likely to be overwhelmed in the streets as they were at the polls."

Well, no matter what we think of him, Ahmadinejad is still in charge by popular demand. We better get used to it.