Friday, July 3, 2009

Climate Change -- Part 2

Is Climate Change for Real?

Anybody that says that they unequviocally, absolutely know the answer to this is either a fool or a liar. Or at least misinformed.

A few miscellaneous facts: (Or at least I believe them to be facts.)

We have a hundred or so years of reliable temperature measurement. I'm not a climatologist but I did take a lot of math in college and to take 100 points and then try to predict the next 100 points in a function that plays out over thousands of years is "an error prone metodology" to say the least. (Its one of those situations where the standard deviation is so large that is masks the trend.) The bottom line is this: We can't use temperature measurements or weather patterns to make a case one way or another.

We do have a lot of data on historical CO2 levels in the atmosphere. Ice core samples from cold places like Antartica, Greenland and Amarillo show that CO2 levels are increasing. And that increase correlates with the beginning of the industrial revolution when the use of fossil fuels increased dramatically.

Water vapor is by far the most prevalent greenhouse gas present in the atmosphere. But that doesn't diminish the role that other GHGs play in regulating the earth's temperature.

There are many scientists that believe that a CO2 level of 385 ppm may be the level where climate change really takes off. We're approaching that level right now. There is no doubt that trend is up.

The concern over the loss of polar ice habitats has caused the US to list the Polar Bear as an endangered species. However, despite what you may have seen in an Al Gore movie, the Polar Bear population is increasing, not decreasing. But wait a second. The population is increasing due to controls on hunting. So will the population decrease as polar ice melts? If it melts.

There are plenty of other facts on both sides of the debate. All researched, sworn and subscribed to by a bunch of really smart people with the best of intentions.

So, here's what I believe about whether or not Climate Change is a fact:
I don't know.

My intuition is that there is probably something there and that wise precautions are in order. In general, the things that we can do to address climate change are good things to do environmentally anyway. So there's no downside as long as we stay within the bounds of reason.

So are we staying within those bounds? That's the topic for our next posting.

No comments: