At the end of Part 3, I closed with the assertion that "The bad news is that the hard problems aren't technical. They are political." Let's talk more about that.
First, let's start with the overall scheme for reducing emissions of Greenhouse Gases. (also referred to as GHG's, these include carbon dioxide (CO2), methane and a whole bunch of other gases, including water vapor, but the gas of principal concern is CO2.) The focus of Waxman-Markey is on the industrial operator -- the power plant, the refinery, the steel mill, etc, not on the consumer. The consumer pays in the end. We'll get to that later but first it helps to understand the overall construct. There are three possible approaches for regulating these emissions: A command and control regime, a tax on emissions, and a market-based system. Let's look at each in turn.
Command and Control
This is the basic system used in most US environmental regulations today. An agency, often EPA or a state agency acting on EPA's behalf, issues a regulation or a permit telling industries exactly how much they can pollute and, often, exactly how to control things. This approach can work in addressing local problems -- a community or a defined geographic area -- but it doesn't apply well to the issue of Climate Change. (1) First, this is because GHGs are a global problem and progress in one geographic area doesn't equate to progress across the entire planet. (2) This approach would have the effect of creating economically and ususally technically impossible requirements on many power plants, refineries, steel mills and other manufacturing causing many to close down or radically change their mode of operation.
This approach is favored by many environmental groups such as Sierra Club, Natural Resources Defense Council and Greenpeace because it causes the most societal disruption and is the quickest way to create a radical reordering of the economy causing massive immediate investment in new, sustainable power sources and immediate changes in individual behaviors. (I know I'm being harsh on those folks, but look past their rhetoric at their actions.)
Tax on Emissions -- The Carbon Tax
This concept is to simply set a tax rate for CO2 emissions, say $50/ton, and let each individual operator figure out his own economics of reducing emissions. This provides economic certainty for the emitter. If he emits x tons per year and the tax is $y/ton then his annual cost is $xy. What this doesn't provide is certainty around the amount of emissions that will be reduced. Since each operator can elect to either reduce emissions or pay the tax, or some of both, then it becomes unpredictable across the economy as to what will happen.(3)
Market-based system -- Cap and Trade
A market-based emissions management system works by using the marketplace to allocate emissions in the most efficient manner. The most common version of this, and the centerpiece of the Waxman-Markey bill is the Cap and Trade system. This system, similar to a GHG regulation system that has been in place in Europe for several years, works as follows:
The amount of GHG emissions allowed in the economy is capped each year. Year on year, the amount of allowable emissions decreases. (See the graph in Part 3, it shows the planned reduction in allowable emissions.) This is the "Cap"
Each year, operators in industries that emit GHGs are granted "allowances" to cover all or part of their emissions.
If an operator's emissions exceed his allowances, then he must purchase allowances from somebody that has extra. If the operator's emissions are less than his allowances he's free to sell them to somebody that needs them.
This exchange of the allowances creates a market place. The laws of supply and demand set the prices. This is the "trade."
Overall, the system makes economic and environmental sense. Since the total amount of emissions in the economy is capped, then there is certainty in attaining the reduction goals. While a market-based system doesn't guarentee cost certainty for the operator, it does an efficient and transparent allocation method and does enable a smart operator to do good planning.
Now, so much for the theoretical. Let's get to the real world and real politics. That's where we're going in Part 5.
Notes
-----------
For more on all of this, here's a good reference. Now the footnotes:
(1) Command and control for conventional air pollution sources as applied in the US is very inefficient and ineffective compared to how it is often applied in Europe and many other countries. A topic for another day.
(2) This begs the question: What good does it do for the US, Europe and Canada to crank down on GHGs while India and China go nuts in increasing theirs? The short answer is that's why the Kyoto Treaty failed 99-0 in the Senate. But it's an interesting question that I'll try to get to in a future installment.
(3) This is the approach favored by some US energy companies , most notably Exxon-Mobil. BP and Shell, both European companies advocated for a cap and trade system. My own opinion is that each side favored the system that played into their strengths. Exxon is a financial powerhouse that can plow through the worst of times and works hard to minimize its financial risks. BP and Shell, on the other hand, are much more cash constrained and, importantly, have very sophisticated energy trading operations which gives them a set of competencies needed to effectively play the emissions trading game.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer: Even though I work in the energy business on some of these issues, these opinions are mine and mine alone. There is no confidential or proprietary information in this post.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Man, I hate it when you oil company shills distort facts to suit your purposes. The Senate vote on Kyoto was only 95-0, not 99-0 as you grossly overexaggerate.
Curiously, among those "not voting" (thus not voting "no") were Feinstein and Reid.
http://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_call_vote_cfm.cfm?congress=105&session=1&vote=00205
Post a Comment