Thursday, January 4, 2007

Universal Health Care: The realities set in.

Writing in the January 1, 2007 NY Times, columnist Paul Krugman breaks down many of the underlying problems with America’s current health care system(link – subscription required) The excerpt below provides a sense of Krugman’s arguments.

The U.S. health care system is a scandal and a disgrace. But maybe, just maybe, 2007 will be the year we start the move toward universal coverage.In 2005, almost 47 million Americans — including more than 8 million children — were uninsured, and many more had inadequate insurance…

A scathing article in yesterday’s Los Angeles Times described how insurers refuse to cover anyone with even the slightest hint of a pre-existing condition. People have been denied insurance for reasons that range from childhood asthma to a “past bout of jock itch.”


Some say that we can’t afford universal health care... But every other advanced country somehow manages... Americans spend more on health care per person than anyone else... Yet we have the highest infant mortality and close to the lowest life expectancy of any wealthy nation. How do we do it?Part of the answer is that our fragmented system has much higher administrative costs than ... the rest of the advanced world. ...



Through my experiences at home and through my involvement with Mainland Children’s partnership. I have seen the financially driven shortcomings in the American Health Care system. This makes me sympathetic to many of Krugman’s points*.

Then, today, I run across this story from the English newspaper, The Times:

Operations cancelled as NHS runs out of money

Patients are being denied basic operations, including treatments for varicose veins, wisdom teeth and bad backs, as hospitals try frantically to balance the books by the end of the financial year, The Times can reveal.

NHS trusts throughout the country are making sweeping cuts to services and delaying appointments in an attempt to address their debts before the end of March. Family doctors have been told to send fewer patients to hospital, [Admissions] departments have been instructed to turn people away, and a wide range of routine procedures has been suspended…

No patients will be given a hospital appointment in less than eight weeks, and none
admitted for elective surgery unless they have waited a minimum of 12 to 16 weeks. Those treated quicker will not be paid for…The trust also announced the immediate suspension of treatments for varicose veins, wisdom teeth, X-rays of the back, operations for carpal tunnel syndrome, bunions, arthroscopy of the knee, and grommets for the ear, among others.



So just when I go believing and trusting in a single payer, centralized system, reality sets in.

--------------------------------
*Although Krugman does let the trial lawyers off the hook. I believe the cost of defensive medicine is not accurately captured. But then Krugman is a died-in-the-wool liberal Democrat so going easy on the trial lawyers is to be expected.

No comments: