I hadn't really been following this story, but I should have been, so thanks ... for bringing it up. I know that part of the state kinda well, which makes this pretty damned interesting.So here's the gary view of all this.... and I apologize up front for the length of this post....
1. The tensions didn't start with some kids sitting under a tree. I guarandamntee ya that there was lots of bad blood preceeding this.
2. The sitting under the tree bit was a provocation by the black kids to the white ones. I'm not saying that's right or sensible, but I'm willing to bet that's what it was.
3. The white kids responded in the most immature and offensive manner possible by hanging the nooses in the tree. Nooses have a special meaning in the South. Whether it was a prank or not, this action was absolutely intolerable and should have been treated as such.
4. Following that, the school board under-reacted horribly. Three students suspended from school for three days. They should have been gone for the semester or the year, if not for good.
5. This brings us to Justin Barker, the white kid that got beaten up. It appears he had nothing to do with the nooses. (If he had, then frankly he would have deserved the ass kicking he got.) What he did probably do is shout a "racial epithet" at the black kids. If that is true, he probably still deserved a good ass-kicking.(As an aside, according to CNN, "Barker's parents say he did nothing to provoke the beating." If my parents only knew the stuff I did at that age... (none of which involved racial epithets, by the way.))
6. The DA over-reacted. Attempted murder, trying one kid as an adult. high bail. He put a match to a powder keg. I take him at his word that his actions weren't racially motivated but that doesn't mean he wasn't a dumb-ass. The time immediately following the beating called for diffusing tensions in the town, not increasing them.
7. Don't get me wrong, the black kids deserved punishment. Aggrevated assault, charged and tried as a juveniles with sentences prescribed by law as appropriate for the crime. No problems with that.
8. The lead defendent, Mychal Bell, is a thug. Four criminal offenses, several violent, three while on probation. He deserves punishment no doubt. However, it apprears in the trial, the DA's dumbassed-ness was overtrumped by Bell's attorney. Letting a teen-aged defendent be tried as a adult with an all white jury in Central Louisiana and not offering a single defense witness? It doesn't take Perry Mason to figure out where that verdict is going.
9. Then the "Civil Rights" community comes along. "Civil Rights" in this context means Al Sharpton, Jesse Jackson and the usual band of celebrities. (Where is Samuel L. Jackson in all of this?) (You know, the most dangerous place in the world to stand is between Al Sharpton and a TV camera.)
10. This bunch are experts at turning fiction into fact and creating victims that don't exist. (Tawana Brawley, anyone?) These guys are getting old and tired and stuggling for relevance. Anytime they can create a situation where CNN AND Fox News is shoving a camera in their face, they feel good again.
11. They are supported by a bunch of college students, who having been born too late for Selma and the real Civil Rights movement, want to get involved in something. This noble aspiration leads them to accept an offer of a nice weekend drive to stay at a decent hotel -- Rooms sold out all the way to Natchez, MS. -- to participate in an experience that they can feel good about and relate to the kids and grandkids. (Yeah son, back in '07, we were in the march on Jena... Why, I bet I've still got the souvineer T-shirt!)
12. The national press eats this up. You got hicks, you've got nooses, you've got celebrities, you've got sterotypes out the wazoo. You even have Barak Obama. It sure beats trying to explain that damned Petreus report again.
To sum up, The following people qualify as dumbasses...
- The black kids for making a big deal out of the tree.
- The white kids for doing the nooses.
- The School Board for not taking the matter seriously.
- Justin Barker for yelling N----- at a bunch of black football players.
- The Jena 6 for giving him a well deserved ass kicking.
- Mychal Bell for leading the party even though he is on probation.
- The DA for over-reacting
- Bell's lawyer for being asleep at the wheel.
- Al Sharpton -- beacuse that's just what he is.
- The press.
- Me -- for spending the better part of an hour writing this.
So here we are, left with a mess that will soon clear itself up and, unlike Selma and the Civil Rights struggles that mattered, will never be in a history book -- unless someone writes the history of early 21st century American Dumbasses.
__________________________________________________
When I first made this post, I sent it to my sister, Gay. She took issue with the protesters and college student remark and probably rightly so. So, in the interests of equal time, here's her take on the protesters....
Gary, we too have been following this story since it was brought to our
attention by our minister on Sept. 4 (see attached email.) I think your analysis
is correct on most points. One item: the people who marched weren’t just college
kids out on a lark. I know this because our minister drove to Shreveport, where
she joined with other clergy, as well as people from both races, for the trip to
Jena for the rally. Social Justice is a core value of Unitarianism, and our
church members are very proud of her participation. I would also be very
confident in assuming that there were clergy from mainline protestant churches
as well. On CNN I saw a brave young pastor in Jena bemoan the racism in his
town.
I’m not sure of the timeline, but my guess would be that Al
Sharpton, et al, didn’t get involved until later – I say this because the
complaint of the UU clergy was that the press had ignored the matter.
After we received your email, I went on the web to check something
(can’t remember what now!), and happened to find our minister’s picture on the
Shreveport Times website. It’s the 28th picture in a series of 42 pictures of
people going to and participating in the march.
http://www.shreveporttimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070920/VIDEO/70920004
- video of people heading to Jena
http://www.shreveporttimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070920/NEWS01/709200330
- good summary of the Jena matter
http://www.shreveporttimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/gallery?Site=D9&Date=20070920&Category=NEWS01&ArtNo=709200802&Ref=PH&Params=Itemnr=28
– Eliza Galaher from Wildflower Church
No comments:
Post a Comment